The CLOSETocracy Myth
A Bit Fruity with Matt BernsteinOctober 30, 202601:33:43

The CLOSETocracy Myth

The belief that a mafia of closeted homosexuals exists within the federal government is not a new one. Neither is the concern that the presence of said homosexuals presents a national security blackmail threat. But the “closetocracy” has found renewed interest not on the openly homophobic right, but within parts of the conspiracy-curious left. When Cenk Uygur of the left-wing talk show The Young Turks announced a documentary called “The CLOSETocracy” about a closeted U.S. senator who allegedly hires gay sex workers, I was excited for my skepticism towards this theory to be proven wrong. After watching the documentary, my skeptecism remains. Today, the gals of In Bed With The Right and I trace the origins of a painful conspiracy and, of course, seek the TRUTH!

Listen to bonus episodes on Patreon!

Thanks to today’s sponsors!

Get 40% off a luxurious faux fur Lola Blanket at https://lolablankets.com/ with the code FRUITY.

Get an exclusive 60% on Incogni! https://incogni.com/fruity

Listen to ⁠my conversation with Jen Welch about this subject⁠.

Listen to Moira and Adrian on In Bed With The Right.

Follow Moira on Bluesky.

Find me on Instagram.

Find A Bit Fruity on Instagram.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

[00:00:00] [SPEAKER_05] We need to start talking about the risk that heterosexuals pose to our national security. Hello and welcome back to A Bit Fruity. I'm Matt Bernstein. I'm so glad that you're here. In the run-up to the 2026 midterm elections, please go out and vote everybody,

[00:00:25] [SPEAKER_05] Cenk Uygur, the host of the popular and longest-running online left-wing political talk show The Young Turks promised us an October surprise. In politics, an October surprise is an event or scandal that jeopardizes a political campaign right before a November election. Think the Trump Access Hollywood tape. Except that, as it turned out, didn't jeopardize Trump's career because we

[00:00:53] [SPEAKER_05] live in a country that profoundly hates women. But anyway, on October 21st, Cenk Uygur tweeted,

[00:00:59] [SPEAKER_01] We're going to drop a bombshell documentary on At the Young Turks tomorrow morning called The Closetocracy. Which U.S. Senator did we catch using male escorts?

[00:01:13] [SPEAKER_05] I mean, hey, I was hooked. I was gripped. Which U.S. Senator was caught using male escorts? Was Tom Cotton caught in the act? Is Josh Hawley a secret homo? Is Mitch McConnell a bottom? It's the only position available to him at this point, to be honest. That's true.

[00:01:37] [SPEAKER_05] Cenk Uygur shared a corroborating post from former Daily Beast reporter Roger Sullenberger, who wrote, Just got a sneak peek of this thing. And I gotta say, pretty compelling stuff here. Cenk continued promoting his forthcoming bombshell. And the following day, The Closetocracy, a 30-minute long compilation of three interviews with current and former male sex workers, was

[00:02:02] [SPEAKER_05] released on YouTube. And the U.S. Senator who hired all three of them was, drumroll please, Lindsey Graham. I have to put in that sound effect that's like, I mean, quick reaction.

[00:02:23] [SPEAKER_01] I don't think anybody was surprised. Like, this was kind of the open secret that Lindsey Graham was, like, A, homosexual, and B, sort of habitually hiring male sex workers in and around D.C. and presumably other places for many years, right? If you were, like, even somebody who paid attention to politics without having a ton of connections, this was almost certainly a rumor you'd already heard. And it was something that a couple of sex workers had already come forward to talk about in

[00:02:53] [SPEAKER_01] public anyway. So I was kind of a little perplexed as to why the Young Turks thought that they were, like, breaking news here.

[00:03:00] [SPEAKER_08] I also think that there's, around D.C., right, it's a pretty active gay scene. And I feel like when I first encountered it, there were sort of politician stories, including about Lindsey Graham, everywhere. So there's what's reported, and there's what's out there, and there's what's just in the community. Wow, you found someone? How fucking amazing. Did you go to any gay bar in D.C. after 11 and, like, buy someone a drink? Because, like, there's gonna be these kinds of stories.

[00:03:26] [SPEAKER_05] With nothing but respect for the three men in this quote-unquote documentary, which we'll talk about more in a moment, this seemed like some pretty cynical bait content from the Young Turks, whose content, which I used to watch, has broadly taken a turn for the bizarre in recent years, which is a whole other story. For one, framing this as a quote-unquote bombshell reveal is a little indulgent, considering, to your point,

[00:03:52] [SPEAKER_05] I think pretty much everyone knew that Lindsey Graham was both gay and hired sex workers. And two, Lindsey Graham is not a U.S. senator. Lindsey Graham is dead. The title of this film is... The title of this film is Closetocracy.

[00:04:12] [SPEAKER_05] The suffix cracy, C-R-A-C-Y, as in democracy or autocracy or plutocracy, denotes a political system or governing body. So, closetocracy should imply a litany of closeted gay people running our country, or at the very least, one example of a living one. But all that's turned up in the Young Turks investigation is Lindsey Graham. Curious.

[00:04:40] [SPEAKER_05] The theory that our government is run by repressed closet cases is not a new one, but it has resurged recently in both the conspiratorial fringe of the America First right and some conspiracy-curious pockets of the left. And a familiar point is often made about these theoretical closet cases, that there's nothing wrong with being a closeted gay person.

[00:05:06] [SPEAKER_05] But doesn't having such a big secret like that make you susceptible to blackmail by foreign agents? Don't closeted gays in the government threaten to undermine our national interests? Hmm. And as someone who's conspiracy agnostic myself, I'm not categorically opposed to this being true, but I want to get to the bottom of if it is. And that is what we're going to do here today. And I'm so excited to do that.

[00:05:36] [SPEAKER_05] Joined by my friends at In Bed With The Right, my go-to queer political psychoanalysts and historians, Moira Donegan and Adrienne Daub. Welcome back to the show.

[00:05:48] [SPEAKER_01] Thank you so much for having us, Matt. It's always such a delight to talk to you. You are such a little ray of light in our lives. And I think we have so much to dig into here.

[00:06:01] [SPEAKER_08] There are a few things that will lure me to the video podcasting format. I'm a very audio guy myself, and I love doing this with you. Thank you for having us.

[00:06:09] [SPEAKER_05] Would you like to give me your top line thoughts about the closetocracy theory of government?

[00:06:18] [SPEAKER_01] Well, it strikes me as kind of old-fashioned in a way. Like something we've been tracing on our podcast, In Bed With The Right, is that actually increasingly gay conservatives are not closeted. A lot of them are out of the closet, openly gay, that there is an established lane for the sort of like performative camp masculinity that we see.

[00:06:46] [SPEAKER_01] In some like gay subcultures to now be wielded for like right-wing ends and as like a right-wing media tool. So this notion of like, oh, the closet case is a, you know, like vulnerable hypocrisy on the right. Strikes me as something that's like really more like 2004, right? This is like more of a artifact of an era where the Christian right was really dominant. And now we have a much more like secular right that is a lot more like

[00:07:15] [SPEAKER_01] publicly sexual and less afraid of having gay people and in particular gay men sort of at the forefront of their movement. So that's one thing I think of. I also am like interested in this notion of gay people as like a nefarious conspiracy who are like secretly running the government. I think that's a really weird idea. Like, have you ever tried to get like a group of more than like two or three gay people to make any kind of decision?

[00:07:44] [SPEAKER_01] Like try to get them to like pick a restaurant? Doesn't happen. Like just coordinate like and let alone like running of like a major federal bureaucracy. Like I just don't think it's going to work out. But this is like the thing about all conspiracies is that they're really good for like offloading responsibility onto like another group and a disfavored group. And I think this is a way that some people on the sort of like conspiracy minded left

[00:08:12] [SPEAKER_01] or like the anti-systems left or what we might call like the low information left to sort of like relaunder reflexive distrust or bigotry they might have into a more like righteous packaging.

[00:08:26] [SPEAKER_08] This felt like the kind of video that they would have put out in 2008 about someone like Lindsey Graham. Right. It's just bizarre for it to come out in 2026 and to be positioned as this big revelation. Like there's a world in which this information might be interesting to someone, but it would be to like a historian of sexuality basically. And to think about like how power, sex work and secrecy sort of interacted in American politics at a certain point. But at the same time, there's also something about this kind of bizarre stunt that feels very of our moment.

[00:08:56] [SPEAKER_08] I do think that some with some regularity, I just wrote a book about Silicon Valley and with some regularity, I get asked to talk about the prevalence of gay men among the sort of tech right. And now on the one hand, you know, we've done episodes of that about that on the podcast. On the other hand, you know, I'm like, I want to be very careful. There are also a lot of straight creeps in that group. I do get the question sometimes in ways that seems to suppose that there is this cabal. Right. And I was like, well, yeah, did they all go to a party together? Probably.

[00:09:24] [SPEAKER_08] But it seems like you want it to be more load bearing than that. And that's where, you know, it can be a very easy vector around which to organize people the way we might organize people around other factors and tell these like very elaborate stories with their identity group in all caps, in case I'm not making myself clear.

[00:09:43] [SPEAKER_05] And indeed we do. But let's first start with the young Turks. So the term closetocracy was originally coined, as far as I can tell, by one Hunter Biden, son of Joe Biden, who's been making an inexplicable media tour or was until he created yet another Hawk to a style crypto coin rug pull scam. Say that six times.

[00:10:09] [SPEAKER_05] Hawk to a style crypto coin rug pull scam, which he called the laptop coin. Dollar sign laptop in which 98% of investors lost their money. I don't want to rant about. I didn't know. I don't want to rant about Hunter Biden on this podcast, but it's like you're a Biden. I don't know how the inner workings of the Biden family trust work. But why are you doing a fucking rug pull scam? I don't know. Hunter Hunter Biden's been pissing me clean off.

[00:10:40] [SPEAKER_05] Also, if you're an investor and like, I don't want to call people suckers, but every time a celebrity does a meme coin, it's a scam. They're all scams. There has never not been one that's a scam. They're all scams.

[00:10:52] [SPEAKER_08] Well, and the guy is most famous for really bad digital security. That's like the thing he's known for. You're like, why would you buy his crypto coin? I don't want to blame the victim here, but come on, guys.

[00:11:03] [SPEAKER_01] The thing I best know Hunter Biden for is that he likes to smoke crack with sex workers. And what is described about Lindsey Graham is similar, like minus the crack.

[00:11:14] [SPEAKER_05] Hunter Biden was on Jennifer Welch's show a few months ago when he coined the term. By the way, Moira and I briefly discussed that in an episode we made about Lindsey Graham right after his death a few months ago. While on Jennifer Welch's show, Hunter Biden said that there was a network of closeted Republican congressmen whose self-hatred manifested in anti-LGBTQ policy. He called them the gay mafia.

[00:11:43] [SPEAKER_00] I believe that the biggest problem in America is in Washington, D.C. with the federal government is not the oligarchy. Closet cases. It's the closetocracy, as I call it. It is. And I'm being totally serious. Everybody knows there is like this closeted gay mafia, largely Republican, that exists in Washington, D.C.

[00:12:10] [SPEAKER_00] and everybody knows every single one of them who's gay. Everybody knows who they are. Everybody.

[00:12:18] [SPEAKER_05] When pressed on this by Don Lemon in a later interview, Hunter Biden did name one person he thought was definitely in the gay mafia. Lindsey Graham. The mafia is just Lindsey Graham. All right. I don't want to get ahead of myself. By the way, I spoke very openly about this with Jen Welch about a month later. Her people called me and were like, we heard you disagreed with our notion of the closetocracy.

[00:12:48] [SPEAKER_05] Come on and talk about it. And we did have an interesting discussion about it in good faith. And I love Jen. And I will link that in the episode description. If you care to see me, hash it out with mother.

[00:12:58] [SPEAKER_08] So the gay mafia thing, that's originally about David Geffen, right? There was a whole thing in Hollywood about a gay mafia sort of in the early aughts. But I think it was people connected to David Geffen. There's a Will and Grace episode where there's a joke that Will upsets the gay mafia. And then it turns out Elton John is the godfather.

[00:13:16] [SPEAKER_05] The first guy I ever hung out with Grindr was once like one of David Geffen's boys. Many moons ago. But it's like, yeah, we're just talking about capitalism. And then one of the people at the top of capitalism happens to be gay.

[00:13:30] [SPEAKER_08] Yeah.

[00:13:30] [SPEAKER_05] Anyway, three months after Hunter Biden coins the closetocracy, Cenk Uygur drops the closetocracy documentary. Before it dropped, Cenk wrote on Twitter,

[00:13:41] [SPEAKER_01] The documentary we're releasing tomorrow on our YouTube channel, The Closetocracy, is about a gay, closeted U.S. senator. The issue isn't someone's sexuality. But there is a serious national security issue. One of the incidents was highly illegal and on tape.

[00:13:58] [SPEAKER_05] Hmm. The documentary comes out and it's about Lindsey Graham, to the disappointment of anyone who thought this project was going to reveal something we didn't know. I will put in clips here. And I head up to the room, knock on the door.

[00:14:15] [SPEAKER_03] And there's, you know, a gentleman. Kind of, like, noticed that he was, like, very professional looking. He had a, you know, a nice haircut. He looked like a different class than I'm used to. And I was like, you know, if this night's going to be a joy for you, like, what are you into? What are you looking for? And he's like, I'm kind of, like, you know, like, dom-sub play. He's like, I really like to be degraded. Like, the more degrading, the better. Maybe a month or two went by. And then I have the TV on the background.

[00:14:44] [SPEAKER_03] And so I hear a voice. And I look at the TV and it's the guy from the hotel. It's Lindsey Graham on the bottom. Lindsey Graham, senator.

[00:14:53] [SPEAKER_07] Mail4Mail Escorts was a site that I was on after a few months of being an escort. I was contacted by Lindsey Graham. At the time, he was a House of Representative member. As I entered the house, I could tell that this part of the house was under construction. So there's open beams. There's black tarp. There's black sheeting. It looked staged like that on purpose. It looked as though it was made or set up to be a film set.

[00:15:23] [SPEAKER_07] Specifically for what looked like, like, very extreme porn.

[00:15:30] [SPEAKER_04] I am Jesse. And I had sex with Lindsey Graham. He began to take off my clothes. He takes off his clothes. I told friends of mine. I wouldn't say that they were surprised. It's not exactly like it's a secret that he was a homosexual. It was entirely oral sex and, you know, jerking each other off.

[00:15:48] [SPEAKER_05] I do want to be very clear in my appreciation and admiration for the three men who came forward in this documentary describing their experiences with Lindsey Graham. I want to say wholeheartedly that I believe all of them. I think there is absolutely no reason not to. I want to give a special shout out to one of the men who appears in the documentary as Corey

[00:16:12] [SPEAKER_05] and who goes by the professional named Sean Harding, who has been sounding the alarm on Lindsey Graham's hiring of gay sex workers since 2020. And I kind of just feel sad that I think this these people's stories were mishandled.

[00:16:33] [SPEAKER_01] You know, something I kept thinking about was like not to like take people back to a time that they don't want to return to. But like January 2018, the babe.net handling of the Aziz Ansari story where it's like, oh, actually, the underlying facts that are being alleged here are pretty bad, but they're being handled in such a salacious way and such a transparently self-serving way by the people

[00:16:58] [SPEAKER_01] who are publicizing them that it really does a disservice to the source. Like that was something that I was thinking of when I was watching this closetocracy documentary from the Young Turks where these guys have, you know, something interesting to say. But the way that their stories are being handled, like the places that the Young Turks chose to like locate the stakes and the controversy of this story was very misguided. I do not think served these men.

[00:17:26] [SPEAKER_08] For one thing, right, it could be just an oral history.

[00:17:29] [SPEAKER_05] An oral history. A. Sorry. Sorry.

[00:17:34] [SPEAKER_08] Like Lindsey Graham in a dark porn set. I just walked right into that. There is a version of this documentary that would be perfectly responsible. And they kind of made it for about 25 minutes of it, but just like put a bunch of like to catch a predator music underneath it to make it something super sinister. And then the documentary never comes out and really alleges until like maybe 30 seconds before the end what Cenk Uygur is actually proposing here.

[00:18:00] [SPEAKER_05] Which I will get to in just a moment. The real kicker in the documentary is that one of these men who goes by Kelvin was hired by Lindsey Graham as a 17 year old.

[00:18:11] [SPEAKER_07] My name is Kelvin. I had sex with Lindsey Graham when I was 17. I think I asked him like, do you still want to do this? And he's like, of course I want to do this. I just have a problem with you not being 18.

[00:18:22] [SPEAKER_05] This happened in 2001, which would have made Lindsey Graham around 46 at the time. And it happened in Arizona where the age of consent is 18. So this implies that Lindsey Graham is not just gay, but entirely more consequentially a pedophile. But the documentary wasn't called pedocracy, which frankly would have been more interesting and relevant in this country, I think. It was called closetocracy.

[00:18:51] [SPEAKER_05] And I have to say, an enormous amount of airtime for a documentary that is supposedly focused on the national security implications of having a closeted politician in such a high rank is spent on the sexual details, the lurid details of these encounters.

[00:19:12] [SPEAKER_03] So he kind of gets up and he's, you know, he's like, I need this spank too. And so I'm like, okay, like, let's get to it. So we leave the couch, we walk over to the bed, he kind of like bends over and you know, I give him like a couple spanks and like, you know, his mood went from timid to kind of like, he's now excited.

[00:19:35] [SPEAKER_04] You know, we begin with like touching each other, engage in mutual masturbation. He wanted to be a little submissive to me.

[00:19:44] [SPEAKER_03] I grabbed him by his neck and spit in his mouth. And I'm like, I was like, is this what you like? And he's like, oh yeah. And I'm like, how about you start to like suck my dick? And he's like, he's like, uh, you know, I'm like, how about you suck my dick, faggot? And he's like, oh yeah, okay. And so like, I picked up, he really likes the word like faggot. He tried to insert his cock into my ass.

[00:20:06] [SPEAKER_07] So I'm like, suck that dick, faggot. He's like, why don't you just take a break and then just, um, try servicing my nipples. Suck that dick, faggot.

[00:20:13] [SPEAKER_05] Suck that dick, faggot. Which I will tell you as a gay guy who revels in some juicy hookup gossip, I was living. I was living. Lindsey Graham likes to be spit in his mouth and called a faggot. Like that's so fun to know. Kind of. See, this is why we're different, Matt.

[00:20:37] [SPEAKER_02] Because I am so upset that I know this. Like that, like.

[00:20:44] [SPEAKER_05] Moira texted me, Moira texted me and was like, this is more than I ever wanted to know about Lindsey Graham's balls.

[00:20:50] [SPEAKER_08] There's so much balls. But it's also, it's Lindsey Graham. If it was a hot politician, I think we could all make a, make an allowance for like, all right, the spit stuff's okay. Maybe not the balls, but the spit stuff's okay. But it's Lindsey fucking Graham.

[00:21:04] [SPEAKER_02] I mean, this is all like to say that this documentary, for those who haven't seen it, the vast majority of these 29 minutes is dedicated to like, who did what to whom sex stuff.

[00:21:18] [SPEAKER_05] And like how hard Lindsey Graham was at various points during the encounters. It was like, he had an erection, but then his erection went down.

[00:21:26] [SPEAKER_07] I looked at his, his, his testicles. It looked like a, like a closed, like a pine cone that hadn't blossomed yet.

[00:21:35] [SPEAKER_05] And I'm like, what? Wait, isn't this about national security?

[00:21:39] [SPEAKER_01] Yeah. Like what his scrotum looked like, what his various kinks were. Like, like these guys, with the exception of the guy who said he was underage, all of these guys do have like pretty similar stories, right? They describe meeting him under similar circumstances, like being hired off of these websites. They describe like similar sex acts, like the kind of thing that could be in the hands of

[00:22:05] [SPEAKER_01] a reporter who is interested in like using that kind of detail to like just establish the credibility of these men. It's like, well, look, they all are kind of telling the same story. That is the kind of thing that you could say without having to front load pornographic detail of it. There's like ways to do this that are more gracious, more dignified to your sources and your subject matter. And frankly, like a little less punishing for your, your audience.

[00:22:32] [SPEAKER_01] Like just as the person who just like does not want to know anything about any, any Senator scrotum at all. But like, this is not what the Young Turks are doing. They are really zoning in very, very detailed onto like, like the mechanics of sex between men in a way that's just like not necessary for any like moral or political case you're making unless what you're trying to do is sort of like titillate and shock and maybe discuss

[00:23:01] [SPEAKER_01] your audience by dwelling on the details of gay sex.

[00:23:05] [SPEAKER_05] This is supposedly some sort of high minded political investigation. And what I'm told over and over again by people, you know, anywhere left of center, I would say, who indulge in this line of thought that there are closeted gay people in the government and that it is a moral duty and a righteous political duty to figure out who they are. It's, it's treated as this noble cause.

[00:23:31] [SPEAKER_05] But what Cenk Uygur has done here, which I think is actually quite revealing, is produced 30 minutes of people talking about the physical details of what Lindsey Graham likes in bed, which again, is a, it's juicy. But is it politically important? Is what we're doing here, does it matter? And, and that's kind of what I want to get into from here.

[00:23:54] [SPEAKER_05] You know, for a documentary framed by its creator as one that exposes a quote unquote national security issue, I was hoping for evidence of that. Okay, fine. It's Lindsey Graham. Maybe that's a disappointment. Maybe I wanted to, like, we knew Lindsey Graham was gay. Maybe I wanted to know another person was gay. But if you're going to give me evidence that Lindsey was blackmailed for being gay, then that's interesting.

[00:24:20] [SPEAKER_05] Yet, the only mention of the issue of national security comes at the end of the 30 minutes, with just a few minutes left, where one of the men offers in a single line that, generally, closeted politicians might be national security threats.

[00:24:37] [SPEAKER_04] When your politicians are engaging in illegal behavior that runs counter to their values, do you not think that that is a national security concern? Do you not think that that raises questions about who knows the information and what's being held over them?

[00:24:53] [SPEAKER_02] It's not a few minutes left. It's like 20 seconds left. 20 seconds. It's like the absolute end.

[00:24:58] [SPEAKER_01] They shoehorn this idea in. And here's the thing for me, is that if Lindsey Graham's, like, status of being in the closet was such a secret, like, if he was willing to do a lot of things to keep this from coming out, then why did all of us know about it long before he died, right?

[00:25:22] [SPEAKER_01] Like, if he was trading national secrets or votes in the Senate to keep people quiet about his sexuality, he wasn't doing a good job because nobody was quiet about this guy's sexuality. It was one of the most transparent closets I've ever seen. Like, not only does the documentary not allege a quid pro quo, they have to ignore the reality that this guy was, you know, all but openly gay in the first place.

[00:25:50] [SPEAKER_01] Like, they have to ignore the reality of just how open a secret this was to even gesture at that as a plausible possibility.

[00:25:59] [SPEAKER_08] I'm of two minds about this because on the one hand, I do think there is a shadowy, scary cabal that probably did blackmail Lindsey Graham, but it's just the Republican Party, right? There was that case in—so after 2008, Lindsey Graham was one of the authors of a comprehensive immigration reform bill, and what would later become the Tea Party went ballistic against him. And as part of the 2010 Tea Party wave, there was this guy, William Gein, down in South Carolina,

[00:26:27] [SPEAKER_08] who on the stump—I forget what he was running for—was like, why would Lindsey Graham, you know, sell out good, hardworking Americans for these awful immigrants, etc., etc.? Could it be that people are blackmailing him because he's so obviously gay? And within weeks, comprehensive immigration reform had died, right? Meaning he sort of introduced this idea of like, oh, Lindsey Graham might be being— might be blackmailed into supporting immigration reform, right? Which is completely fantastical.

[00:26:53] [SPEAKER_08] But of course, what he was doing in the moment was actually kind of blackmailing Lindsey Graham, being like, get back into the tent or else. So not only, I would say, as Maura's saying, like, is it not a big deal? It was very, very open. It was part of his appeal to the Republican Party. It made him very pliable. It made him very easy, right? He was—Lindsey Graham always was attached to another politician. He was always the amigo, right? You never saw this guy alone.

[00:27:19] [SPEAKER_08] Attached to John McCain, attached to Joe Lieberman, then to Donald Trump, right? He always sort of would show up in these packages. And I think part of that is why they liked him, because you could barnacle him to other things. And part of that was that they felt, whether or not justifiably, I don't know, but they felt that he was pliable on account of this secret that everyone knew. And that's a sign of a deeply homophobic society. It's a sign of a deeply homophobic party. But no one's being driven to a third location here. It's not particularly conspiratorial.

[00:27:50] [SPEAKER_08] It's just like it is what it is to be part of a hate movement.

[00:27:53] [SPEAKER_05] There's a lot of people on, like I said, sort of the conspiracy-friendly, the conspiracy-curious left, and the conspiracy-driven, particularly the, like, Groyper-adjacent America First right, who would like to attribute, I think, a lot of Lindsey Graham's destructive policy decisions in government to this sort of blackmail scheme. And something that you'll see a lot if you go on right-wing parts of the internet, which sort of mirrors what Cenk is doing here with his Young Turks documentary,

[00:28:22] [SPEAKER_05] is like, why was Lindsey Graham working so fervently on behalf of the interests of Israel? Was it because the Mossad had something out on him and his sexuality or his hiring of male escorts? And it's like, well...

[00:28:38] [SPEAKER_01] I'm sorry, then how do they explain all the straight people who do that shit?

[00:28:42] [SPEAKER_05] I'm sorry, like... How do you explain the straight people? Well, and also, like, Lindsey Graham was gay, and he was also a power-hungry racist, which those attitudes align well with the interests of both Israel and the United States.

[00:28:57] [SPEAKER_01] But it's interesting to me that, like, you touch on this notion that Graham's homosexuality and his, like, nominal closetedness are becoming associated in the conspiracist mind with his support for Israel. I do not think that every critique of Israel is anti-Semitic. Let's, like, put this here. Like, many critiques of Israel are just humanitarian or, like, pro-democracy or anti-racist. I don't think that is always true when you get to these, like, fringe,

[00:29:26] [SPEAKER_01] particularly, like, right-wing nationalist critiques of Israel, which, like, can have, you know, moments where they partake of this logic where it's like, well, Israel is bad because it's a Jewish country and Jews are evil, conspiracy-minded, you know, tribalist, whatever. And I think that there's something about the way that anti-Semitism operates as this, like, imagined conspiracy that looks a lot like the way homophobia is operating in this notion of, like, the closetocracy.

[00:29:54] [SPEAKER_01] It's like, oh, man, there's this, like, group of people who all have something in common and they're among us, but they're not like us. And they are, like, sort of conspiring in these, you know, dark rooms behind closed doors to, like, rule over us. And, like, once again, I just do not think you can get that many, like, try getting that many gay men to keep a secret.

[00:30:14] [SPEAKER_08] It's also the question of, like, if you took a look at all of Lindsey Graham's votes that he took in Congress, all the positions he took on foreign policy, what part of that would suggest to you that if it weren't for this dark secret he's harboring, he would be not supportive of Israel? He's like, the man famously loves bombing Arabic countries. And, like, it's, like, sure, like, if people reached for that as an explanation for, like, a very strange about face or, like, an unusual, right? If, like, Lindsey Graham suddenly came out in favor of same-sex marriage,

[00:30:44] [SPEAKER_08] I'm like, oh, shit, did someone get to Lindsey, right? Like, are we then supposed to assume that Lindsey Graham was this, like, dyed-in-the-wool liberal but never got to live it because they were just, like, uh-uh, Lindsey, we got that tape, right? It's, like, over, like, 40 years. Like, no, the man was passionately, was a passionate neoconservative, loved bombing other countries, fucking loved it. Even more, if I may say so, than having spat in his mouth, right? So, his real fetish.

[00:31:11] [SPEAKER_01] Well, I mean, like, here's the thing. Like, the Young Turks, they're trying to suggest that he was a racist neocon because he was gay. And I think what we're all trying to say is, like, no, he was a racist neocon and he was gay. But, like, you actually cannot establish a causal relation here. It does not follow.

[00:31:27] [SPEAKER_05] Right. And in this documentary, he barely tries, but he pretends to. Lindsey Graham trended at number one on Twitter in the U.S. for the entire day of the documentary's release. Lindsey Graham has been real quiet since this came out.

[00:31:51] [SPEAKER_05] Cenk reiterated that the true concern of the film that he had put out was national security. And while many people were critical of the documentary's lack of truly new information or about a senator who was alive, even, one person did applaud it. Former congresswoman and famous friend to gay people, Marjorie Taylor Greene, wrote, and strap in because since leaving office, I don't think she has a comms person anymore.

[00:32:20] [SPEAKER_01] On Lindsey Graham. Stay with me on this. Oh, no. The worst kept secret in Washington, D.C. came out today because three brave men came out and told the truth. And it doesn't matter if it's after he's dead. Brave? Yes, brave. Why are they brave? They had to go on camera and tell intimate details of their personal lives to the world. That is extremely difficult to do. Yes, it's brave and stressful.

[00:32:45] [SPEAKER_01] They walked into the public square, opening themselves to the opinions of the entire world. No matter your opinion on the issue, they took a courageous leap in coming forward. If you are critical, would you go on camera and tell your secrets to the entire world? I bet a lot of money you wouldn't. Okay, but there is more to this. Because this is the world I saw up close in Washington. I saw behind the curtain and saw all the wizards.

[00:33:10] [SPEAKER_08] Wizards. All the wizards.

[00:33:11] [SPEAKER_01] Everyone in the highest levels of power in D.C. are keeping secrets that would destroy their entire lives. And that's exactly why they have power. Not because they are so smart or qualified or the best choice for leadership. Their secrets are the only reason these people rise to the top. Because their secrets are not secrets. We all knew Lindsey Graham was gay. Everyone did. Their secrets are levers. God, this goes on for so long. I'm sorry. Their secrets are levers of control. Keeps them in line.

[00:33:40] [SPEAKER_01] Makes them a team player. And will make them fight the hardest on issues that don't make sense in order to keep their secrets just that. Secrets.

[00:33:48] [SPEAKER_05] Long ass tweet. I'm going to clip some of that out. It's like you just rambling.

[00:33:53] [SPEAKER_01] It just goes on and on.

[00:33:55] [SPEAKER_05] Cenk Uygur quote tweeted this with a 100 emoji. Now, if Marjorie Taylor Greene and Cenk Uygur are such warriors for truth and opening the public up to these secrets that everyone in power has and that is driving their decision making, why not tell us?

[00:34:21] [SPEAKER_05] She says, I saw behind the curtain and saw all the wizards. So, why aren't you telling us? Look, I'm not saying I'm not like so anti, anti, anti, anti, anti this theory that I will say like none of them have secrets. I mean, the Epstein files are a thing that we still do not know the bulk of the information within them.

[00:34:45] [SPEAKER_05] Because, as we all know, the Republican side, to her credit, minus Marjorie Taylor Greene and Thomas Massey, have relentlessly tried to keep secret. So, I'm not saying that nobody has secrets. But, two things. One, the idea that like closeted gay people are like a uniquely dangerous class of people within this government is something that I just keep hearing these people say and none of them providing evidence for.

[00:35:13] [SPEAKER_05] And perhaps the more important point generally is that the things driving the decisions of the people in power are things like capitalism. I would argue that's actually the biggest thing driving most of the people in power. Look at the things that motivate Trump. It's making his family more money and cementing a legacy of himself in all of his patriarchal glory.

[00:35:38] [SPEAKER_05] These are the things that motivate people to do extraordinarily bad things and not feel badly about them. And I think the problem is that talking about those systems and racism, by the way. And I think talking about those systems that drive the average person to do horrible things is like not sexy or interesting. It's not fun. I always say this on this podcast. It's not fun to talk about systems.

[00:36:05] [SPEAKER_05] It's not fun to talk about capitalism. It's a lot more exciting to imagine that every single person in government has some like wild basket of secrets that's keeping them in line. And not just the fact that they're in debt to all the fucking corporations that donate to their political projects.

[00:36:26] [SPEAKER_08] She's onto something in the sense that elite impunity cuts both ways, right? You get away with stuff that other people cannot, but you're bound to that elite because if you start speaking out against other members of that elite, you basically are in a glass house throwing stones, right? So I think that's something we saw a lot with me too, that if one boss falls over this, like the next one might too, because they're like, oh shit, I've done something very, very similar.

[00:36:51] [SPEAKER_08] So the fact that there's kind of a duality to that and they can actually create a powerful bond for an elite, I think that's true. At the same time, she uses the word gay like four or five times of this. And like, this ain't a gay thing. And then also she's just, she makes it out to be this like very conspiratorial thing when what this is, is like something any sociologist can tell you. It's how power operates in society. And yeah, it sucks. And like there are ways to prevent it. Getting money out of politics would be one of them, right?

[00:37:22] [SPEAKER_08] But very clearly she's sort of thinking like, oh no, there are individual actors who sort of need to be isolated, brought down, kicked out of government. And then this goes away.

[00:37:31] [SPEAKER_01] This notion that the closet has more power than other kinds of secrecy is I think something that relies on like morally isolating homosexuality in a way that I don't think is defensible if you're just like trying to like make the case on the merits.

[00:37:48] [SPEAKER_01] Like no, homosexuality is like more taboo, more shameful, more secretive than other kinds of like sexual secrets or like secrets about like divided loyalties or like lost integrity. I like, I don't really think that it's like morally special that way.

[00:38:07] [SPEAKER_01] And I also don't think that the closet like quite has the amount of power that people are attributing it to like to make this case, at least not for like the kind of people who get elected to office, which are like rich adults, right? Like I think the closet is like very high stakes for like a trans or like gay teenager in like a rural like religious family, right? Like I think that person's closet is like very high stakes and they will probably like go out of their way to preserve it.

[00:38:36] [SPEAKER_01] I think for somebody like Lindsey Graham, the closet was like mostly a matter of convenience. It was about using plausible deniability to smooth over some contradictions, which is something that you see people doing for things that don't have a lot to do with sexuality, for like things that are like ideological compromises or contradictions that they're inhabiting for like all kinds of relationships that they're living in. And I just like don't understand.

[00:39:05] [SPEAKER_01] I don't understand how these people are making a case about like the uniqueness of the gay closet if it's not about like trying to create a cover for homophobia.

[00:39:17] [SPEAKER_05] When I brought up my reservations about this closetocracy theory, including on Jen Welch's show, a lot of people will comment. The problem is the hypocrisy. They're gay. There's nothing wrong with that. But they support anti-gay laws. And I agree. But that's not really what we're talking about because the stakes of this conversation are always raised to a place of national security concerns.

[00:39:45] [SPEAKER_05] And so, look, what if we're wrong? Maybe, despite Cenk and Marjorie not offering so much evidence in this particular case, maybe closeted gay people are a threat to national security. They're keeping a secret after all. Who's to say that secret can't be exploited? I'm not predetermined to agree or disagree with this theory. I just want to know the facts.

[00:40:11] [SPEAKER_05] And I think a look at history can help us gain a better understanding. I would like to take a quick break from the show to give a shout out to Lola Blankets for sponsoring this episode. Lola Blankets are currently the world's number one blanket. And for a reason, I've actually had mine for like three months now. But before getting it, I saw some of the marketing for Lola Blankets and I was like, you know, it's a fucking blanket.

[00:40:41] [SPEAKER_05] Like how soft can it really be? And the answer is, it really is that soft. I think the best way to describe a Lola Blanket is it's like the nicest, most luxurious possible version of a completely faux fur blanket. It feels like a marshmallow hugging your skin. And the only real downside that I found is you won't want to get up once you're enveloped in it. Lola is machine washable. It is double hemmed for total durability.

[00:41:10] [SPEAKER_05] And it won't pill or shed even after repeat washes. If you want the perfect blanket this fall to cozy up with and watch TV or sleep with, which I often do nowadays, you can get 40% off select Lola Blankets at lolablankets.com by using the code FRUITY at checkout. That is 40% off with the code FRUITY. And by the way, I did a little homework for you.

[00:41:37] [SPEAKER_05] I went to the website and I added a bunch of blankets to my cart and put in the code FRUITY. And I got 40% off on almost every single one of them. So just saying. After you purchase yours, Lola Blankets will ask you where you heard about them. And if you want to support the show, let them know that you heard about them from A Bit Fruity. This show is also sponsored by Incogni. AI cybercrime is on the rise, according to Axios.

[00:42:02] [SPEAKER_05] Meaning that hackers and other cybercriminals are increasingly looking to use AI tools to scale their attacks, surpass digital barriers, all sorts of other great stuff.

[00:42:17] [SPEAKER_05] Fascinatingly, I did also just read a Wired article about how anti-cybercriminal activists are also increasingly using AI to trick the cybercriminal AI into talking to bots that appear to be human victims. Everyone's using AI for everything, which makes me feel awesome.

[00:42:42] [SPEAKER_05] Anyway, the less personal information about you that's available online, the better. And Incogni is one tool that helps you limit that. Incogni basically reaches out to hundreds of different data brokers, which are these companies that mine your personal information, your name, your address, your phone number, your social security number, your education, your shopping habits, your job interests.

[00:43:07] [SPEAKER_05] That information gets bought and sold by these data brokers all the time. And Incogni reaches out to them and demands that they delete your stuff from public record, which is something that you have the legal ability to do yourself, but it would just take an extremely long time to try. Incogni gives you regular updates on a very easy to understand dashboard about how progress is going, getting your personal information off the Internet.

[00:43:35] [SPEAKER_05] So you always just feel like you have a handle on it. If you want to get your personal info out of the hands of data brokers, you can get 60% off an annual plan at Incogni today at incogni.com slash fruity. That is incogni.com slash fruity. So I want to talk a little bit about something called the Lavender Scare.

[00:43:59] [SPEAKER_05] And before I talk about the Lavender Scare, Adrian, would you like to inform the audience about how, before the great purging of homosexuals, Washington, D.C. became a home to many of them?

[00:44:11] [SPEAKER_08] Yeah. D.C. grew a lot during the 30s and 40s, a side effect of the New Deal. And what was already a pretty considerable LGBT, what we use today would call LGBT nightlife, really becomes a burgeoning kind of queer community. And it had a lot of newcomers, right? A lot of people who were new to town, not a lot of established families, which sort of made it easier, right?

[00:44:35] [SPEAKER_08] You could go to a gay bar and not lock eyes with like your uncle or whatever and be like, oh, shit, like now I got this thing to deal with, right? Like it created a kind of anonymity that was really, really important for queer nightlife at the time. And at the same time, it was a pretty visible queer community. I think the first depiction of a gay bar in a Hollywood movie is in Advise and Consent from, I think, 1959. And that's set in D.C.

[00:45:02] [SPEAKER_08] At the same time, there was this real concern in the federal government about the presence of especially gay men, but not exclusively gay men, mostly in the armed forces, where this was this idea that like, yeah, there was sort of sapping morale, they were sapping manliness from the troops and whatever. And it was often framed in terms of kind of psych assessments. So the first places where really people were flat out asked, are you gay? Was sort of around the war effort, right?

[00:45:27] [SPEAKER_08] And this is where a place like San Francisco does become the gay haven that we know today because people got discharged and then dumped out in San Francisco. But by the 1940s, late 1940s, when this sort of becomes standard practice in the federal government, there's this additional reason. It's not that they're sick or that, you know, they're unmanly. No, it's that they are security risk.

[00:45:51] [SPEAKER_08] There were then efforts made above all by people like J. Edgar Hoover, you know, famous heterosexual, to actually actively ferret people out. Because you could imagine like this is just a question on the questionnaire. Everybody lies, whatever. No, there were real efforts made to ferret out gay people in government.

[00:46:08] [SPEAKER_08] So this meta concern about security risks, right, where moral arguments become overlaid with sort of anti-communism and talk about sort of national strength, you know, and this conspiratorial McCarthyite narrative of subversion is really powerful for two reasons. One, it's a morality argument that never has to sort of be openly moralistic.

[00:46:29] [SPEAKER_08] It's also it creates this weird circularity, which is that the federal government starts firing people that they suspect of being gay or know to be gay. Usually this would take the shape of an arrest at a gay bar or like in a bathroom in the case of Walter Jenkins, LBJ's chief of staff. And then the presence of that basically means gave someone like McCarthy more fodder to be like, see how many there already are. I bet you there's even more, right?

[00:46:58] [SPEAKER_08] And that's the famous lists and so on. So this had this kind of weird sort of circularity that like the federal government, frankly, is sort of paranoically rummaging through its own files, right, and trying to match up police arrest records with their their HR records produces then the positives that would allow sort of the anti-queer sort of anti-communist element in Congress to kind of be like this problem. It goes ever deeper. Right. So like everything confirms this.

[00:47:26] [SPEAKER_08] Absence of evidence confirms it and evidence also confirms it.

[00:47:29] [SPEAKER_05] Right. I think most people are familiar with the term the Red Scare, which was the 1950s purging of federal employees, members of government who were suspected of being communists, communist sympathizers. And the Lavender Scare, which was the purging of gay or suspected gay federal employees or officials, was really tied up in that. But I think people don't know that the Lavender Scare actually affected many, many more people than the Red Scare.

[00:47:58] [SPEAKER_05] Some estimates showing as many as 10,000 federal employees were fired on the basis of sexuality or suspected sexuality. And the commonly held belief at the time was that communist sympathies were intertwined with sexual deviance.

[00:48:15] [SPEAKER_06] Homosexuals must not be handling top secret material.

[00:48:19] [SPEAKER_01] I love this idea of like, like, OK, capitalism is our robust, manly, masculine economic system. And it's under threat by these like failures of gender in the form of like gay men who are secretly infiltrating our federal bureaucracy. It posits gay men is like both like very weak. Right. And very strong at the same time.

[00:48:43] [SPEAKER_05] Which is also just such a great depiction of how systems like capitalism and patriarchy work hand in hand and always have. But that's not as fun to talk about as like speculating about conspiracy theories. In 1952, the New York Times officially started reporting on the Lavender Scare, which of course was not called that until the 2000s.

[00:49:10] [SPEAKER_05] They reported 126 perverts discharged. Nice, nice, nice. 1953, President Eisenhower, who campaigned on quote unquote cleaning house, signed Executive Order 10-450, which explicitly barred homosexuals from employment in the federal government, which set the stage for a wave of mass hysteria wherein thousands of people were tried.

[00:49:36] [SPEAKER_05] Which trial style on the basis of their sexuality and fired if they proved to fail their heteroness. Similar restrictions, by the way, lesser discussed, were placed within state and local governments across the country. And these homo trials were architected by Joseph McCarthy, a Republican senator, famously homo questionable himself.

[00:50:04] [SPEAKER_01] Famously heterosexual Joseph McCarthy. Definitely 100% straight as an arrow Joseph McCarthy.

[00:50:11] [SPEAKER_08] And his right hand man Roy Cohn.

[00:50:13] [SPEAKER_05] And his right hand man Roy Cohn, himself a gay man who later died in the closet of AIDS.

[00:50:19] [SPEAKER_08] Cenk Uygur, do a real blow by blow of Roy Cohn. Guys, you're not going to believe who's gay. Right. My first clue.

[00:50:31] [SPEAKER_05] Hi, I'm Cenk Uygur and I'm about to expose a closeted attorney, Roy Cohn. For years, though, there were witch hunts, wiretapping, widespread paranoia among Washington, D.C. People were fired from their jobs over the cadence of their voice and the way that they walk, all in the name of national security. So, like, I know it gets, like, kind of put in the footnote of history.

[00:51:00] [SPEAKER_05] It's also, as so much of gay history is, undocumented because many of the victims of it were reluctant to document or come forward about what was happening to them because speaking out loud about what was happening to them would require outing themselves. So people just lived in these clouds of shame. There are testimonials from the time from people who were in D.C. that, like, people just stopped making friends. People stopped going out. Everyone stopped trusting each other.

[00:51:28] [SPEAKER_05] There were people who were brought forward to trial in front of Joseph McCarthy and Roy Cohn, literal Salem witch trial style, who were told to name six other homosexuals. It was nuts. And some people didn't survive at all. Andrew Ferentz was a 34-year-old from Uniontown, Pennsylvania. He graduated from high school in 1937 and served almost four years in the Army before attending Penn State University.

[00:51:58] [SPEAKER_05] He began working for the State Department after college as a 23-year-old. And in 1950, he was transferred to Paris, where he worked as a research assistant for almost four years. When he was confronted by U.S. federal agents who interrogated him about his sexuality and ultimately coerced him into confessing that he was gay, for which they forced him to resign.

[00:52:24] [SPEAKER_05] So, shortly after, while still in Paris, he locked the doors and windows of his apartment, filled it with toxic gas from his stove, and died. Government officials lied to Andrew's family about the nature of his death, saying it was a result of a, quote-unquote, inactive lung lesion. And newspaper clippings from the time that still exist online today, which I will put on the screen if you're watching the video version of this episode,

[00:52:49] [SPEAKER_05] say that Andrew resigned from his job because of, quote-unquote, ill health. The government routinely did this covering up of Lavender Scare suicides. Another man shot himself in the street after being outed and fired. And a federal agent later admitted that he and the security people on duty that day were the only people who knew.

[00:53:11] [SPEAKER_08] So this is the pressure that's being brought to bear by the federal government itself. Of course, also, in the 40s and 50s and 60s, we see a much greater sort of police crackdown on this stuff. And big vice squads kind of doing these entrapment beats. There were cops that just kind of like professionally hung out at gay bars and got oral sex performed on them. And they were like, and now you're arrested. Which, yeah, I mean, like, I'm just going to leave that there. But that was a job description, essentially.

[00:53:38] [SPEAKER_08] Meaning, it's not just that the federal government is really viciously going after these people. At the same time, from below, you have all these local police departments kind of generating lists of, quote-unquote, deviance of sex perverts that they keep arresting. Because it's not like, you know, you have the federal government, which is uniquely vigilant. But they're the only ones gathering this data. No, there is just, there is also an out-of-control kind of local police apparatus in almost every major American city.

[00:54:07] [SPEAKER_08] Basically, trawling every fucking gay bar that they can find to try and entrap people.

[00:54:12] [SPEAKER_05] I do love the idea of a police officer in like the 1950s who's like, Every weekend, I go to bathrooms in gay bars and get head from men to investigate. It's like, sister, what are you doing in the bathroom?

[00:54:27] [SPEAKER_01] Yeah, this actually went on way later than you would think, though, Matt. Like, you're talking about the 1950s. But like, these sodomy criminalization laws were in effect and like being enforced with some regularity up until 2003.

[00:54:41] [SPEAKER_05] Mm-hmm. Okay. So, I don't want to indulge in history for history's sake. I am doing this because the questions raised around the potential security threat of closeted gay federal workers during the Lavender Scare sounds a lot like the theory proposed by Cenk Uygur and his contemporaries in this current thinking around the closetocracy.

[00:55:08] [SPEAKER_05] So, we've established that during the Lavender Scare, our United States government threatened and coerced members of government into disclosing their sexuality, which is one of the ironies of the Lavender Scare is everything that was being accused of federal workers who were thought to be gay. Okay, the people actually doing that sort of spying and threatening were our own government. Okay, but did other governments?

[00:55:34] [SPEAKER_05] Wasn't that supposedly the threat, the reason we were doing all of this to begin with? Well, the closest thing I could get to finding a single documented example of closeted gay employees of the U.S. government being blackmailed into working for a foreign government was this. And it is, at best, a tenuous example. There's an article about this, and I would like one of you to read the headline.

[00:55:58] [SPEAKER_01] How the Reds blackmail homosexuals into spying for them. It ends in a big exclamation point.

[00:56:03] [SPEAKER_05] How the Reds blackmail homosexuals into spying for them. The FBI knew those two code experts were fruity fellows. Hey, fruity. But nothing was done about it until the boys had already minced off to Moscow.

[00:56:20] [SPEAKER_05] How many more pansies do we have in strategic positions whose perverted pursuits in hotel rooms have been caught on cameras by cunning commie agents to be used as blackmail bait to make the homos turn against their homeland?

[00:56:34] [SPEAKER_02] On the one hand, the nominal complaint, even here, even in this case, is that homosexuality makes homosexuals liable to blackmail. Right? But even in the rhetoric, it's creating the conditions for that to be possible.

[00:56:50] [SPEAKER_01] Because it's being like, okay, these guys are already suspicious and corrupt and bad in some way by virtue of being quote-unquote fruity fellows. And therefore, it's not so much like, oh, they're going to be blackmailed into cooperating with the Soviets. It's that they're already kind of like pieces of shit anyway, right? Yeah.

[00:57:13] [SPEAKER_02] And so it's like a real weird, like, moral logic here. It's like, well, what is your actual complaint?

[00:57:18] [SPEAKER_06] Exactly.

[00:57:18] [SPEAKER_01] Are they vulnerable to blackmail because we live in a homophobic society where gay people will try and conceal their conduct? Or are they already corrupt and therefore liable to go be spies for this, like, enemy state?

[00:57:36] [SPEAKER_02] It's like, you can't actually decide.

[00:57:38] [SPEAKER_08] Exactly. Why would people that this country hates and prosecutes hate this country? It is bizarre.

[00:57:44] [SPEAKER_01] Yeah. Well, it's also, it's like these people are being cornered by homophobia into acting in ways that we don't like. And therefore, we better be more homophobic.

[00:57:55] [SPEAKER_05] But also, did they act in ways that we don't like? Did they commit espionage for Russia? Let's find out. Vernon Mitchell and William Martin were two men who worked for the NSA, National Security Agency, in the 1950s. And in 1960, the pair relinquished their U.S. allegiance and defected together to the Soviet Union. Romantic. Curious.

[00:58:22] [SPEAKER_05] Once in Moscow, the two men gave a press conference where they criticized a host of U.S. policies, including the U.S.'s habitual spying on allies, provoking other nations by invading their airspace, and heightening the possibility of nuclear war, which the two men were vehemently opposed to.

[00:58:42] [SPEAKER_05] Congressman Francis E. Walter, a member of the House Un-American Activities Committee, or the HUAC, labeled the two sex deviants, which he says he'd heard from someone.

[00:58:55] [SPEAKER_08] Oh, so they were just two dudes, but HUAC made up that they were gay?

[00:58:58] [SPEAKER_05] They were literally two guys. Hang it out. Nothing gay here, fellas. And this one congressman, Francis Walter, saying that he'd heard from somewhere that they were sex deviants, led to the press running with this story that the two men were traitorous homosexuals who fled to the Soviet Union to live in their, I don't know, traitorous homosexual communist fantasy. Sounds fun. Hearst newspapers referred to Martin and Mitchell as, quote,

[00:59:27] [SPEAKER_05] two defecting blackmailed homosexual specialists. That's great. And a, quote, love team. Again, romantic if true. The New York Times speculatively called them longtime bachelor friends, and suspicion grew that the two were part of an organized group of compromised homosexuals. Of course. Some in the HUAC suggested giving all new hires polygraph tests to avoid hiring homosexuals in the future.

[00:59:56] [SPEAKER_05] As a product of their fleeing to the Soviet Union, the NSA announced that it had fired 26 people suspected of being, quote, sexual deviants as well. But were these two men gay? And if they were, was their homosexuality the reason for their defecting? Had they been blackmailed by the Soviet Union to move across the world and work on their behalf? There is basically no evidence of this.

[01:00:23] [SPEAKER_05] Most of the reports that have been done on this case and released since revealed that these two men were just sort of strange, anti-social men who thought that they would be more well-respected in the Soviet Union than they were in the U.S. They basically felt like they were really smart and talented. They weren't being given their due in the U.S. They also disagreed with a host of U.S. policies, and they went to Soviet Union where they thought they would be more respected. An NSA report called them, quote,

[01:00:59] [SPEAKER_08] Which, by the way, is the actual profile of Cold War defectors, I think. It's often personal pique and professional frustration. Like, it's not, it's got nothing to do with sexuality. It's just people whose careers have stalled out and they think that they're not being valued. It's like throughout the Cold War, that appears to be the kind of person who would defect or, on both sides of the Iron Curtain, or would go double agent.

[01:01:24] [SPEAKER_05] It also does seem like they were sort of like struggling socially. Allegedly, Martin was a, quote, incurable alcoholic. Another NSA report in 1963 found no clear motive for their defection. And then reports recovered by journalists at the Seattle Weekly newspaper in 2007 featured sworn testimonies from women who said that the two men were heterosexual,

[01:01:48] [SPEAKER_05] and sometimes even hypersexual, they had orgies with multiple women. Wow. Good for them.

[01:01:57] [SPEAKER_01] I mean, I like the idea of the two lovers, like, defying capitalism and, like, becoming these, like, convinced communists and running away together. That's such a better story, actually, than, like, just narratively, than these, like, oh, this is kind of, like, maladjusted guys. They were sort of, like, antisocial losers. And they just sort of, like, had a bond over a shared sense of not being given their due. Like, that's kind of boring. And it's, like, so banal. And it's so much, but it's, like, so much truer to life.

[01:02:27] [SPEAKER_01] Like, very few people have these grand love stories where they are, like, their sex lives are the object of, like, international interest. That's just a much sexier story. But it's also a story that allows people to, like, off-source all of their fear and responsibility for their own, like, operational security onto this, like, disfavored minority population.

[01:02:47] [SPEAKER_05] There's no evidence that, like, these two men were, like, gay people, blackmailed into being gay, went to the Soviet Union to be gay homosexual communists together. But it was just retroactively applied because the government needed a case study to justify their own ongoing persecution of people they thought might be gay within the U.S. government. Like, it was just manufactured hysteria all the way down.

[01:03:15] [SPEAKER_05] And this case is the best evidence that comes out of the Lavender Scare for why the Lavender Scare was happening. There are zero documented examples of closeted gay government employees being blackmailed into working on behalf of a foreign government. None. In fact, a study conducted by the Department of Defense, conducted by the government, examined

[01:03:43] [SPEAKER_05] 117 instances of federal employees who did commit or attempt to commit espionage between 1945 and 1991. We'll read a passage from that case.

[01:03:57] [SPEAKER_01] Six of the center's 117 recorded espionage cases between 1945 and 1991 involved homosexuals. In these six cases, the study found that fear of having one's homosexuality disclosed was not the motive for disclosing the nation's secrets. Instead, the motives appeared to be the same as in most espionage cases, primarily money and secondarily resentment. All volunteered to provide national security information except one who was recruited as

[01:04:25] [SPEAKER_01] it accomplished by a heterosexual friend.

[01:04:27] [SPEAKER_05] We need to start talking about the risk that heterosexuals pose to our national security. Yeah.

[01:04:37] [SPEAKER_08] I should say that there is a famous British case where something like this was in play, but even that doesn't quite conform to the Lavender Scare playbook. And I know we're going to be talking about honey trapping later, I'm guessing. But there is a guy, John Vassal, who worked for the British embassy in Moscow in the 1950s and who did sort of participate in Moscow queer nightlife and got filmed doing it.

[01:05:04] [SPEAKER_08] And basically, the Soviets did blackmail him into spying for them. So that is a case. But this is someone who, you know, is not working for the government in Britain, right? Like you're not getting honey trapped in London. This is happening in Moscow. But this happened to straight embassy workers all the time.

[01:05:25] [SPEAKER_05] The thing that really stuck out for me from this study that the DOD actually attempted to hide and then ended up being published by someone else was like even the six out of 117 espionage cases that were committed by homosexuals, it had nothing to do with the fact that they were gay. They just either wanted money or hated America, which like, you know.

[01:05:51] [SPEAKER_01] Understandable. It happens.

[01:05:54] [SPEAKER_05] Whom's among us? It happens. So, I mean, this just isn't happening in the way that people think it is. It has never been happening in the way that people think it is. And I feel like people don't know that. And I feel like people should because the same things that people were saying about the supposed risks of closeted U.S. officials in the 1950s look identical to what people are saying today.

[01:06:23] [SPEAKER_05] And if there's evidence that it is happening, I'm happy to be wrong. But there just isn't. Should we talk about honey traps and heterosexuals? Oh, please.

[01:06:36] [SPEAKER_01] This is actually kind of a crazy trend, particularly during the Cold War, but not only. But there's a lot of people in the U.S. who are intelligence assets, who are going to be in possession of useful information for foreign governments, who are working in the State Department or in the Defense Department or what have you. Just by sheer numbers, most of those are straight men, right?

[01:07:02] [SPEAKER_01] And so if you are a foreign government looking to blackmail somebody or extract information, your best bet if you're going a sexuality route is by using a woman and trying to use her to entrap a man. And we actually do have a lot of examples of this working successfully, of American possessors of

[01:07:29] [SPEAKER_01] state secrets falling for this and it having to get covered up rigorously later. Like I'm thinking of fucking Jack Kennedy, who like John F. Kennedy famously had an affair with a woman who was a Nazi asset during World War Two and his family had to cover that shit up when he ran for president. And that is like now like kind of de facto common knowledge. But nobody's saying, well, you know, straight men are idiots and they think with their dicks.

[01:07:56] [SPEAKER_01] And so we can't give them national security secrets because if you said that you would sound insane.

[01:08:01] [SPEAKER_08] The Soviet Union did use honeypots copiously. Obviously, right. I'm a historian of Germany, my day job. And like it was huge there because, of course, you had agents that spoke without an accent, right? You could just get an East German agent, bring them to Bonn and have them strike up a friendship. And they had two versions, the Venus trap, which was exactly what Morris describing. You have a pretty young agent, sort of a female agent tempt a famous politician or usually the person working for them. Or you had what's called the Romeo trap.

[01:08:30] [SPEAKER_08] And that was the same thing with a, you know, KGB hottie or Stasi hottie. And the idea was you'd get that guy's secretary. This was a country in which many there were many widowed young women right after the war. And, you know, they met this nice guy at a cafe and eventually they were making an extra Xerox for him of everything that their boss did. Right. And like they were fully exploiting the tragedy of heterosexuality. And the gay stuff was like, yeah, I think ancillary. Right.

[01:08:58] [SPEAKER_08] Like it just, you know, if anything, the Cold War is a massive monument to the folly of heterosexuality.

[01:09:05] [SPEAKER_05] Eric Swalwell. Yes. Had a relationship with an alleged Chinese spy in the early 2010s. He had a three year long physical, what he called physical relationship with a woman Christine Fong, also known as Fang Fang, who was an alleged Chinese spy living in the United States for a time who struck up relationships, romantic and physical with a number of high profile men in the U.S.

[01:09:35] [SPEAKER_05] government before going back to China with all of the information she had received from them. I didn't even know this about Eric Swalwell. And I have to say that if a gay person had done this, gay people as a whole would be put in the camps. We would never be allowed near office again. And Eric Swalwell was front runner for California governor this year. Yeah. Until details of even more of his sexual improprieties were revealed.

[01:10:04] [SPEAKER_01] Yeah. Alleged drunken rapist Eric Swalwell did something sexually reckless and stupid. I'm shocked. And like, you know, this is plausible. So easy to imagine it. It's like very easy for me to imagine the like absolutely banal way in which somebody like this gets close to somebody like that. You know, like Eric, Eric Swalwell is like a big dumb idiot just begging to be scammed. And like his heterosexuality was a tool of his own legitimacy in accessing like positions

[01:10:34] [SPEAKER_01] of power where he was able to be manipulated that way.

[01:10:37] [SPEAKER_08] Historians can contradict me if I'm wrong here. But my sense is also that in some ways the kind of honey trap operation really lends itself more to a heterosexual relationship in the sense that cruising in the 1950s and 1960s was a highly anonymized and sort of place specific thing. You wouldn't run into the same person over and over again. Someone like Fang Fang obviously is building a relationship over years, right?

[01:11:03] [SPEAKER_08] You cultivate an asset, meaning that's hard to do when you're like, oh, I finally like hooked up with this amazing, you know, like high up in whatever the State Department. But now he's switched gay bars. And I don't know how to have a second tryst so that I can then get him to betray his country. It's like, I just can't find him. I just keep visiting glory holes. And it's just not him, right? Whereas, you know, like it fits much better in these, you know, sort of year long recruitment things. I'm not saying that homosexuality and heterosexuality are different in that way, but the way they

[01:11:32] [SPEAKER_08] were lived in 1960s, you bet your ass it was different. You could bring someone into someone's office as a secretary, wouldn't maybe get that serious background check and have them sort of become the honey trap. Queer life was furtive and was secretive, meaning it was hard to build these and was often built around avoiding rather than creating sustained and traceable relationships, making it making recruitment for a honey trap so much harder. Yeah.

[01:11:57] [SPEAKER_05] Yeah. So I think we've established just by the numbers. I feel very like I feel like I need to be like very like preemptive and defensive because every time I've talked about the closetocracy and why I don't necessarily think that it's real or legitimate. I always just get a million comments being like you don't get it and you don't understand. And so I would like to put for the record that just by the numbers we have loosely established

[01:12:21] [SPEAKER_05] here that in fact, male heterosexuality is a bigger threat to national security than male homosexuality. But why do these theories stick? Why in the face of zero evidence do we continue repeating these lies over decades about the supposed risk of closet cases in the government? I want to talk about the structure of conspiracies.

[01:12:50] [SPEAKER_05] And I want to start by saying that I was sitting on a plane a few days ago on my way out of Ohio where I was for Kat Tenbarj's wedding. Mazel tov, Kat Tenbarj. Congratulations.

[01:13:02] [SPEAKER_01] Congratulations, Kat. We love you.

[01:13:04] [SPEAKER_05] Lesbian weddings are the best, by the way.

[01:13:06] [SPEAKER_08] Every podcaster in America other than Maura and myself appears to have been at this wedding.

[01:13:11] [SPEAKER_05] I was on the plane back and I was thinking about this episode that we're recording now when I looked over at the older woman sitting to my left who had been scrolling Facebook for several hours. And I took a picture of what was on her screen. Sneaky, sneaky, I know. Sorry. I wouldn't usually do that sort of thing. But it was so unbelievably racist that I wanted to send it to the group chat.

[01:13:37] [SPEAKER_05] And what it is, is a photo of Abdul El Saeed next to a photo of Zoran Mamdani, both looking Arab with the text.

[01:13:47] [SPEAKER_01] Both El Saeed and Mamdani are evil men that practice taqiyya, parentheses, a concept in Islam that says it is okay to lie, deceive or conceal their true beliefs if it serves a higher purpose, close parentheses, as part of their radical Muslim faith.

[01:14:01] [SPEAKER_05] Now, this is extremely racist and insane. But I've actually seen this circulate particularly Islamophobic parts of the internet quite a lot. I actually first...

[01:14:13] [SPEAKER_08] That's because you follow Debra Messing.

[01:14:15] [SPEAKER_05] Oh, you beat me to it! I literally was about to say, I first saw this theory of taqiyya on Debra Messing's Instagram story shortly before the New York City mayoral election. And what strikes me about this line of thinking, which basically says that Muslim men who are

[01:14:38] [SPEAKER_05] aspiring to office are concealing, no matter how progressive they might seem and no matter how or what someone like Abdul El Saeed or Zoran Mamdani says about their respect for women, their respect for LGBT people, their beliefs in equality, their progressive bona fides, etc., no matter what they say, if they're Muslim, they are by nature obscuring that they are really

[01:15:06] [SPEAKER_05] conservative religious fanatics who will enforce Sharia law and subjugate all minorities. And it's going to happen. And they're just hiding it from you. But really, they're conspiring behind the scenes for their true desires. And what strikes me so much about this conspiracy is it resembles the anti-Semitism I've been familiar with my entire life.

[01:15:32] [SPEAKER_01] Yeah, I like to think of anti-Semitism as sort of like this like code for other conspiracy theorizing. It's like one thing that people say about conspiracy theorizing and conspiratorial thinking is a sort of all roads lead back to anti-Semitism. Like eventually, if you keep following that line of thinking, if you keep like going down those rabbit holes online, you'll get to and it's all the Jews doing it.

[01:15:58] [SPEAKER_01] But I do think it like anti-Semitism provides like a template that you can apply when you're looking at this like conspiratorial thinking about like a minority group or a disfavored group, right? This notion that these people have loyalties to each other, that they have a world that is theirs. And that even though they are sort of among you, even though they are part of this, what

[01:16:25] [SPEAKER_01] looks like this general sort of community or this broader American public, that really they have this other loyalty that supersedes that loyalty, that really they have this other agenda. And that kind of like notion that there's an in-group somewhere that is different from you, but they are alike to each other and that they are controlling things, that they have a sort of set of projects that they're hiding from you, but they're all pursuing together.

[01:16:54] [SPEAKER_01] Like that is the core myth of anti-Semitism. And it is the core myth behind a lot of these. Like I think, you know, anti-Semitism obviously has its like maximalist dangers, right? But I also think that it isn't just like dangerous because it can encourage violence. I also think it's dangerous because it can make you stupid.

[01:17:18] [SPEAKER_01] Think critically about like the actual existing like Jewish people or gay people or Muslim people that you know. Think about what their actual incentives are like. Think about what their actual characters are like. They don't all like each other. Like one thing we've seen a lot through the course of this episode and that you actually weirdly see as a contradiction, I think, in a lot of this like closetocracy conspiracy theorizing

[01:17:44] [SPEAKER_01] about gay men is both that like all homophobia can be explained by recourse to like gay men's sexual shame is like one thing. It like completely offloads responsibility for homophobia from like homophobic straight people. But also it's this notion that they all hate themselves. They all hate each other. They're working against each other. But also they're all conspiring together against us. Like those two things don't compute. You see this a lot in anti-Semitism, the idea that like Jewish people are both responsible

[01:18:14] [SPEAKER_01] for like all of the excesses of capitalism and also all the dangers of communism. Like they're both like Bernie Madoff and Bernie Sanders. And it's like, well, those those guys don't get along. Like they're not hanging out, like not in the real world.

[01:18:27] [SPEAKER_08] It's just two guys. It's just two guys.

[01:18:29] [SPEAKER_01] But, you know, it's like this notion that the suspect identity or the suspect quality like overrides every other thing we know about these people's actual lives. And I just think that it's more logical and more consistent with what I see of like my actual world, even though it's like less narratively titillating and and less of a good story to think that like gay people, Muslim people, Jewish people like they're people with a whole bunch

[01:18:58] [SPEAKER_01] of different incentives and conflicting beliefs who don't always get along with each other, who are managing to balance those identities in a bigger conflict of like other identities and other priorities that are existing simultaneously and that they're probably going to act a lot like other similarly situated people would act. But the conspiracy theory doesn't make room for that simultaneity of incentives. It just says this idea is like, no, no, no. It's this thing.

[01:19:25] [SPEAKER_01] This feature is what unlocks everything you need to know about the world. It's like so simplifying in a way that I think makes it very appealing to people.

[01:19:32] [SPEAKER_08] There's also a kind of weird essentialism right at the heart of it that I think you're putting your finger on. Right. And modern antisemitism emerges in the 19th century as kind of cognate or coefficient of modern nationalism where it's like what are we like as a nation and who doesn't fit. And I think it's very telling the structure of like there's someone I identify as not me. And then I say either that person is different from me and that's sinister or worse. They're actually acting exactly like me.

[01:20:01] [SPEAKER_08] And that's even more suspicious. Right. Like the thing that a conspiracy theory about Al-Sayed and about Mamdani can entertain is that like this is a Michigan boy and a guy who really loves living in New York and they just happen to also be Muslim. Like that can't be it. The fact that, you know, this one person is a guy who is Jewish who runs a bank and this is a guy who hates bankers. Right. They just both happen to be Jewish. The idea of sameness and difference sort of like the fact that you sort of can't assimilate

[01:20:30] [SPEAKER_08] out of a conspiracy theory, I think is something that is very true for sexuality. Right. Like there is always a fear of these people don't try to be like us. That was even worse is if they try to be like us. Right. Like throughout all the 90s, like we were told that like, oh, if gay people just kind of like buttoned up and became more respectable, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, the homophobes wouldn't hate us quite so much. But then you get to like that and it's like, oh, no, but now we can't tell. Right. Okay. Well, I don't know how to please you people. Right.

[01:20:59] [SPEAKER_08] But this kind of duality that comes still out of the 19th century, I think is really

[01:21:04] [SPEAKER_05] central here, too. And, you know, when people claim that Jews or Muslims are conspiring to hide their identity and control or undermine the government, people correctly understand that as bigoted and conspiratorial. Well, most people. Let me not erase Deborah Messing from this conversation. But when people claim the same about supposed gay people conspiring to hide their identity

[01:21:32] [SPEAKER_05] and control or undermine the government, there is a liberal or even left wing adjacent strain of thought that says this is woke. We saw that in Jenks tweet promoting his closetocracy documentary where he wrote the issue isn't someone's sexuality. I promise it's not. But there is a serious national security issue.

[01:21:57] [SPEAKER_05] Liberal types will often profess their support for gay people while insisting there is a higher moral reason that it is righteous to investigate someone's alleged homosexuality. This manifests in something I might call woke homophobia.

[01:22:13] [SPEAKER_01] You know, what I always feel when this comes up is like, no, no, no, it's just about the hypocrisy. It's not about the like underlying sexuality or it's just about like the national nominal national security risk. It's not about the underlying homosexuality. Like what's really consistent to me is the feeling that what is being revealed by people like the Young Turks

[01:22:41] [SPEAKER_01] and Cenk Uyghur is like, OK, your opposition to homophobia, your like acceptance of gay people is not principled. It's provisional. It's a matter of assessing that like, OK, it's not useful for me to be homophobic towards guys who are on my side. But I will deploy that against guys who are not on my side. Right. Which means that you're sort of like keeping it in your back pocket against the guys who are on your side.

[01:23:06] [SPEAKER_01] Like if they piss you off, if they're not useful anymore, if they sort of disappoint you in some way, then suddenly homophobia becomes fair game again. That's what's really kind of revealing to me. It's like, OK, this is not a principled opposition to bigotry. This is a strategic deployment or reserve of bigotry, like based on your own ends.

[01:23:29] [SPEAKER_05] I also like I don't know how you guys feel about outing. I feel like everyone has a slightly different feeling about outing. I think and I've talked about this on this podcast before in the context of people like Aaron Shock. I think people who do harm the community on like a federal policy level and who are, you know, sucking and fucking behind closed doors. I'm not necessarily mad when they are outed. I'm not mad at all.

[01:23:59] [SPEAKER_05] But in a way, it's a conversation that I really only trust queer people to have and to lead. Because when someone like Cenk Uygur takes the wheel and it's not handled in a way that I think actually benefits queer people. It's just turned into a salacious like he likes doing what in bed? Yeah.

[01:24:20] [SPEAKER_01] I'm like kind of of two minds of the idea of like whether hypocrisy is itself like an issue of moral seriousness. Like to me, what's most offensive about Lindsey Graham's like anti-gay stances is that they impacted other people. Right. Like it's not particularly important to me if Lindsey Graham hates himself. Like I hate him, too. That's something we have in common. Right. Like like what's more important to me is the way he used his material power, which was the same way that a lot of like, you know, straight people use their material power.

[01:24:50] [SPEAKER_01] Like something we haven't really mentioned is that like there's this constant accusation that I think is like well taken and true, which is that like Republican men who are in the closet are hurting and hating the people they sleep with.

[01:25:04] [SPEAKER_01] Like that's also true.

[01:25:33] [SPEAKER_01] Of all these Republican straight men who are voting against abortion rights, who are like decrying women as childless cat ladies. Right. Like this idea that like contempt and desire are being mixed in this way that is like deeply problematic. Like I have news for you. That's true of straight people. Like that happens across the sort of spectrum of sexuality.

[01:25:57] [SPEAKER_05] I think that's a great point. And I want to finish this episode by making clear that I am no fan of the closet. Do not mistake my critiques of a conspiracy theory about closeted gay people as an endorsement of the closet. I hate the closet. I think it destroys the life of the person inside it and oftentimes hurts the people around them.

[01:26:22] [SPEAKER_05] I understand the utility of the closet, especially for people who are marginalized and vulnerable. But I also hate it. And I think that's probably something we can all agree on more or less. Moira, when we were texting before this episode, you said of the closet, quote, quote, it really is a moral compromise or failure to live in that kind of dishonesty. I think that's provocative. I promised I would give you space to expand on that. And your time has come.

[01:26:51] [SPEAKER_01] Yeah, this might be one of my hotter takes, right? It's like I do think the closet, like qua the closet, like in the abstract, right? It is a kind of dishonesty. Like when you are closeted, as I think we have all been at various points in our lives, like you are lying. You are concealing important information that might indeed have a bearing on those around you, right? That is a moral compromise.

[01:27:17] [SPEAKER_01] That is something that I think closeted people are morally culpable for. And this, I think, isn't an undermining of the closet's violence or of homophobia's violence. I think it's a product of homophobia's violence. Like what homophobia does when it pushes people into the closet, when it makes it difficult to live just an honest life or incentivizes a dishonest life, is that it compels dishonor.

[01:27:46] [SPEAKER_01] Like this is what its injury is, is that it puts you as a vulnerable gay person in a position of having to choose between telling the truth or like getting hurt. And that's unfair. That's just not something straight people have to do. The concept is called moral injury, right? Which is like, no, you're put in a position where you kind of can't do the right thing or doing the right thing costs you so much more than it would cost somebody else under

[01:28:15] [SPEAKER_01] different circumstances. That is a kind of injury. And it's an injury, I think, like to the soul a little bit. And I don't think it outweighs the strategic need of the closet for vulnerable people. I think your point about the closet's utility, Matt, is really well taken. But when you're looking at somebody like Lindsey Graham, you're like, okay, I think this guy is dishonorable in a lot of ways. But I'm sorry, somebody like Junk Wigger and the Young Turks are creating the conditions

[01:28:44] [SPEAKER_01] where being gay is a professional liability, where being gay is putting you under this like lens of suspicion, right? And that's creating the conditions that incentivize this kind of dishonesty. That's creating the conditions that make it harder for people to live this just like one kind of honorable, straightforward, honest life. And I think they're culpable for that as well.

[01:29:08] [SPEAKER_05] I was just at the movie theater the other night and I saw La Bola Negra. I don't know if either of you.

[01:29:13] [SPEAKER_08] Oh, you saw that.

[01:29:14] [SPEAKER_05] How is it? I really think that everyone should see it. I think that it was the best movie that I have seen this year. And I did also see that Elizabeth Holmes Nathan Fielder movie. And I do think this one was better, though it was also almost three hours. We've got to start editing folks. We've got to start editing our movies because it's so hard to hold your pee for that long. But without giving really anything away about La Bola Negra, one of the takeaways from it

[01:29:42] [SPEAKER_05] is how the closet is a hazard, how the closet is destruction, how the closet destroys not only lives but generations in a really complicated and traumatic way. And I think it did a beautiful job of depicting that. But it's a complicated and traumatic destruction that I just don't think most cis straight people

[01:30:09] [SPEAKER_05] understand, which is why I don't usually trust them to handle stories as complicated as that of the closeted politician. And I don't know. I think Cenk Uygur has given me yet another reason to not trust them. But, you know, congratulations on the AdSense money, I guess. I don't know, you guys. What should I do now? I'm going to make a documentary called The Heterocracy.

[01:30:37] [SPEAKER_01] Yeah.

[01:30:38] [SPEAKER_05] The Heterotocracy.

[01:30:40] [SPEAKER_01] Talk about like movies being too long now. Like that documentary, five, six hours. We're talking like Ken Burns level.

[01:30:47] [SPEAKER_08] It's just going to be Matt just walking somewhere filming people and just like pointing. This. Also this.

[01:30:56] [SPEAKER_05] Thank you, both of you, for excavating a conspiracy theory with me. I hope I've left people willing to walk away from this being like, I don't know, just like slightly less interested in in people's sexualities. And I hope that doesn't sound like, you know, ruining someone's fun or whatever. But one thing I've learned from the past few years of being Jewish in public and actually

[01:31:22] [SPEAKER_05] something that I think most minoritized people, especially trans people over the last few years know really well, is that it's not good to be the topic of conversation all the time. Yeah. For people to be hyper fixated on a small portion of the population and the way that that marginalized group engages with their identity. For that to be the topic of national discussion all the time is not healthy for the people in that community.

[01:31:52] [SPEAKER_05] It always results in hatred. And I just think that we should stop my compelling ending.

[01:32:06] [SPEAKER_01] I just like, there's so much to object. There's so much to object to Lindsey Graham over other than the fact that he was a gay man. Also, he's dead.

[01:32:15] [SPEAKER_05] Also, he's dead. He's really dead. Like he is dead. He is as dead as someone could possibly be.

[01:32:21] [SPEAKER_08] Dead as a doornail.

[01:32:22] [SPEAKER_05] Move on, everybody. Moira and Donegan. Moira and Donegan. Moira and Adrian. Thank you so much for joining me on this episode of A Bit Fruity. Would you like to remind people where they can find more of you and your excellent gay analysis, historical analysis, gay historical analysis?

[01:32:43] [SPEAKER_01] I'm at The Guardian. Adrian is a writer everywhere. And together we are the hosts of your new favorite podcast, In Bed with the Right. So you can find us there.

[01:32:53] [SPEAKER_08] Wherever you listen to podcasts, you'll find us. And also we're on Patreon. Just putting that out. Our producer tells me to say that every time I can.

[01:33:01] [SPEAKER_05] You have a producer. Fancy.

[01:33:03] [SPEAKER_08] I know. Hence the need for a Patreon.

[01:33:07] [SPEAKER_05] That's real. That's real. Thank you so much for tuning into this episode. Please go out and vote because you might not feel super motivated to vote, but you know who does feel super motivated to vote? That lady who is sitting next to me on the plane reading Debra Messing levels of racism in her fucking Facebook feed. She's voting. I can guarantee it. So you better be too. I love you so much.

[01:33:35] [SPEAKER_05] And until next time, stay fruity. And you're in the audience.